The Woman in Cabin 10 #mystery #suspense @ruthwarewriter

The Woman in Cabin 10 by Ruth Ware

Audiobook narrated by Imogen Church

Published by Simon & Schuster Audio, July 2016


It feels so weird to me that I am reviewing a book that pretty much everyone else has read. That doesn’t happen often at Grab the Lapels, as my original mission was to champion little presses, find new voices, and focus on women. However, my book club chose this book, and I was mostly happy that Ware fits into my “ladies only” theme! The Woman in Cabin 10 was difficult to procure (a protest I raised when the book was chosen), and I was only able to get the audiobook. If you’re never tried audiobooks, the good voice actors tend to have more emotion and bring multiple characters to life rather than simply “reading” the story. The bad voice narrators: pee-yew! The big downside, though, is that audiobooks take what feels like forever to get through. And I listened to Imogen Church read Ware’s book for almost two weeks.

The Woman in Cabin 10 is about British journalist Lo Blacklock, who has managed to settle for a job at Velocity, a magazine about travel. Not exactly the investigative stuff Lo dreamed she’d do after college. When her boss cannot attend a work event on a luxury boat, the Aurora Borealis, Lo goes instead, hoping this is her chance to show she deserves a promotion. The night before she is set to leave on the ship, she wakes to find a man in her apartment. He traps her in her room and robs the place. Lo is frazzled, feels violated, perhaps breaks up with her boyfriend (she’s not 100% sure that’s what they decided), and boards the Aurora Borealis for a week. As a result, Lo doesn’t sleep much for days. She has a drink (or several) to calm herself down. Ware sets readers up clearly to have an unreliable narrator. Because, of course, something has to happen.

The first night, as Lo dresses for dinner, she remembers her purse was stolen during the break in, so she has no mascara. She bangs on Cabin 10’s door and borrows some from a young woman, whose room looks unkempt like that of a teenager’s. Later, sleepless, Lo is startled in the middle of the night on the Aurora Borealis, sure she’s heard a scream and a splash, sure she see’s blood on the railing of the veranda to Cabin 10. But when ship security finds nothing and shows her Cabin 10 is empty, the doubts flood in.

Imogen Church is an excellent voice actress. Her voice soothes; I wanted to listen. Church narrates Blacklock’s fear with trembles in her voice and urgency in her pleas. Every sentence is rich with emotion. However, this is what slows the reading time down. Also, the audiobook has really long stretches between tracks. The chapters of the book are each one audio track, meaning if I didn’t have 30-45 minutes, I couldn’t start a chapter for fear of losing my place. With a book, I may read 10-15 pages and stop, which takes about 10 minutes.

cabin-10

Since my husband is in the book club too, he procured a copy of The Woman in Cabin 10 and was patient enough for the hardcover version. I compared his text to what I had listened to. During the break in, Lo thinks the following: “Please, I thought. Please don’t hurt me. Oh God, where was my phone?” But Church’s voice digs up the terror. I was scared for Lo! Honestly, I’m not sure I would have enjoyed the hardcover book. All the pleading might have sounded forced, and thus I recommend the audiobook over the hardcover edition.

I also noticed that Church uses different voices for all characters. Many of the employees on the Aurora Borealis are Norwegian. Church does them all with accents in addition to male and female British passengers, some who sound husky, others who are jovial. Church captures Lo’s boyfriend, Judah from Brooklyn, too. In the hardcover version, though, none of the voices are written in dialect. It would have been easy for me to forget that so many characters are Norwegian and that the Aurora Borealis is headed toward Norway. Basically, the voices reinforce the setting.

While I tend to avoid mystery-thriller books for their predictability or outlandish plots that attempt to avoid the unpredictable, I mostly appreciated The Woman in Cabin 10 for all the smaller issues Lo points out. For example, she doesn’t feel like she belongs on the Aurora Borealis because the rooms are around $8,000 per night. Lo notices the ship is like a doll house: everything extravagant, but sized down. The staff have such small quarters compared to the guests. The staff rooms aren’t bad — the staff note that their quarters are much worse on other ships — but the smallness of the rooms for the workers strikes Lo, and I appreciated Ware’s attention to class differences.

Also, Lo points out that the women guests are tiny, sleek, hungry-looking, while the men are rotund and could survive a shipwreck for ages. The double standard — men can be fat and powerful while women must almost disappear to be noticed — stood out to me in a positive way. Ware’s narrator doesn’t float through reality, she pays attention to it. Smartly, the narrator’s attention to class and gender come back ever so subtly in the last ten or so chapters of the book. You may have even forgotten there’s a connection, but if you’re paying attention too, you will be rewarded.

Although Hollywood films would have us believe strong women must shoot weapons, save worlds, and practically be ninjas (all while wearing form-fitting leather), Lo Blacklock is a strong woman with a regular personality and body.

Katniss.jpg
Notice her breasts and abs; that’s how tight it is. She’s amazing with weapons, and the wings suggest a divine savior of sorts, like an angle. Spare me.

She can’t climb over high walls, and the stairs may make her a bit winded. But she defends herself. When security on the Aurora Borealis suggest Lo may have not seen or heard anything that first night, she tells the man to stop speaking because he doesn’t have a right to make her feel crazy or shut out her voice. Security mentions that another passenger said Lo drank a lot and that she takes anti-depressants. Such a combo is sure way to destroy a person’s authority, but Lo throws security out of her room for such utter disrespect and lack of concern. If only all women could stand up for their own voices — and that includes me — what a different world it would.

Advertisements

54 comments

  1. Simon and Schuster Canada just sent this book to me, but the blog tour doesn’t start until January. Which is kind of annoying, because I’ve read lots of UK blogs that have reviewed this book too. Gosh, we are so behind here in North America sometimes 🙂

    • I’m in Indiana, actually. The book came out in July 2016, so I’m not sure why the book tour is in January. Do you mean the author is doing the book tour? She might be making the rounds in the U.K. first and then visiting North America. The book is here, though! Mine came from the library.

  2. Enjoyed your review. It is good that we are getting strong women leads but I agree that they are often just pseudo (fighting) men. Pacifism requires strength too, but that is not a point often made. I listen to audio books all the time, more than 100 per year, and the advantages, as you point out, of being read to by an actor are enormous. Maybe the best recently has been Reese Witherspoon’s reading of Go Set a Watchman. But you need time, probably travel time, I couldn’t imagine sitting around the house listening. And yes mp3’s with limited breaks are annoying.

  3. It’s very cool to read your thoughts on audiobooks vs. hardcover. I’ve never listened to an audiobook, but will definitely be remedying that shortly. A cruise ship is such a fascinating place to set a mystery (when I went on a cruise my sister and I came up with several murder mystery ideas :)). It’s an isolated place with many many interesting characters doing very interesting things. How was the mystery itself?

  4. I have in fact never listened to an audiobook. I’d like to, but I suspect my attention span isn’t very long. And I also like to read at a certain pace, so I could see myself just giving up the audio in favor of a hard copy. Glad this one worked out for you.

  5. Great review! You really make a case here for trying audiobooks. I’ve never listened to one before, and have always been concerned about the time aspect. But your notes about the different accents and the different emotions added makes me want to try an audiobook sometime. I’ve heard that Thandie Newton’s narration of Jane Eyre is really excellent to listen to.

      • Ooh. Yeah, he would do a great job on that book. He was excellent in the movie. Not sure I could stomach reading/hearing that book again though. The way he spoke the first and also the final lines in the movie were so haunting. I can imagine what listening to him narrate the whole book would be like!

  6. Brilliant review! I have read and reviewed this book but reading this post has made take note of things that I hadn’t thought about. I read the hardcover and the issue on accents was totally lost on me. I can’t even remember much about the characters apart from Lo. I also like the issue that you mentioned about class differences. I noted that too because of the different quarters and where Lo ended up being held. I like that you focused on the protagonist and her strengths too. Great review!

  7. Haha when I read the title, my first thought was “I can’t believe she read a book I’ve heard of before” lol

    I find that listening to thrillers via audiobook is the way to go! It heightens the suspense in my opinion. I often wonder after finishing a well done audiobook if I would have enjoyed it as much via print form…

    “Although Hollywood films would have us believe strong women must shoot weapons, save worlds, and practically be ninjas (all while wearing form-fitting leather)”

    Amen sister!

    • I know, right?! Usually I get build from small press authors, but this was my book club’s choice. The Carli Lloyd book that I reviewed just before the Ware book is mainstream and very new, but I read that one out of curiosity.

  8. I’m glad to read your positive review of this. It’s on my TBR and I’ll get it pretty soon from my library (I’m close to the top of the holds list.) One of my co-workers and a library patron both told me recently that they didn’t like it because they found the narrator “whiny” and annoying. I said, well, I’ll try it and see. I don’t have to like my main characters to enjoy a book. I just have to find their actions believable.

  9. I love how Lo sounds. So likeable. Sounds very Bernadette meets Girl on the train. (I know. I’m doing the unforgivable comparison thing). But I still haven’t read this so your review wasn’t in vain!!! Haha

  10. Hey, you! This sounds pretty cool :). I’m a fan of audio books since a few years ago when I had a twice-daily commute of an hour. Totally used to consider it cheating, but I’ve found several favorites via listening. And you’re right–the narration makes or breaks it. I’ll have to check it out now :). Maybe I’ll request our library buys it.

  11. I love your review! I haven’t read the book but yes, it is refreshing to have a heroine who does not shoot a gun and have a 23-inch waist. 🙂 I publish guest reviews on my site, Always Write (marshajustwrites.com). I would love to publish this post as a guest post on my site, if you are interested in doing that, with a links back to your site, of course. Let me know what you think. 🙂

      • OK, still a great review. If you change your mind, let me know. BTW I think I read that you live in IN. That’s where I’m from. I grew up in Indianapolis. My brother and I went back for a visit for his 60th BD and had a great time remembering places and friends and seeing new places. Have a great December. 🙂

  12. Ok I re-read your review after having read the book, and I completely agree with all of it, and makes me think, maybe I should be listening to audio books? But I just don’t have time for that! Also, I loved how the class and gender differences showed up in this book, it made me respect Ware even more.

    • I find it’s best to listen to them in bed. It’s dark, so there’s nothing to distract you. I also tend to walk more when I’m listening to an audio book just so I make time for it. If you’re thinking about how often you want to review a book on your blog, audio books can be difficult, but I’m slowly loosening up a bit on being obsessed with posting X number of times per week and enjoying reading more.

      • See this is the challenge of being a book blogger. All you want to do is read books, but you have to post about them too! Other bloggers have it easy, they don’t have to read a whole book first before they post something 🙂

  13. Great review, Melanie! I find it really difficult to concentrate on audiobooks. Not sure why. Such a convenient way to read though! I’m a big Ruth Ware fan (like so many other reviewers). Highly recommend her first book, In a Dark, Dark Wood. I found it a little creepier than The Woman in Cabin 10. Also, hope you’re well and enjoying the holidays! 🙂

Insert 2 Cents Here:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s