*Scroll down for the text review.
After reading All Hallows’ Evil by Valerie Wolzien for Halloween — and this was just a book that I found in Goodwill and bought for the cover — I was surprised by how much I liked the main sleuth, homemaker Susan Henshaw. Published in 1992, All Hallows’ Evil came out long before “momfluencers” or mommy bloggers who push to make mothers (hello, where are the dads???) more creative, effective parents with healthy (probably unvaccinated) children that have never tasted a Skittle. Of course, before moms tried influencing people online, they did it in person, and Susan Henshaw ain’t here for that, which is part of what cracks me up. She won’t stand for being talked down to because she’s “just” a homemaker/amateur sleuth. Seeing that Susan has a whole series (The Connecticut Murders), I immediately said NO to that. NO MORE SERIES! But Susan has a Christmas book, and she did bring a lot of joy to my Halloween…. And the while All Hallows’ Evil (#4 in the series) was just fine as a stand-alone novel, the characters develop across a larger arc….
GAH!
Okay, so the entire series costs something like $6 on Kindle, so I bought it and started at the beginning with the goal of getting to #3, We Wish You a Merry Murder before Christmas. And then I roped my mom and cousin into reading it with me for our book club, so if I’m getting jolly, I’m bringing those hags down with me.
ON TO THE REVIEW!
Murder at the PTA Luncheon (#1) felt more police procedural than cozy mystery/amateur sleuth. We are literally following Detective Brett Fortesque and Officer Kathleen Somerville, state police sent to a wealthy suburban community in Connecticut after two women on the local PTA (Parent Teacher Association) were murdered. Detective Fortesque clocks Susan Henshaw as the kind of woman who observes but not for gossip, and so he trusts her perception of all the suspects. Thus, Susan is not the main character of Valerie Wolzien’s first novel in the series. Perhaps it was never envisioned as a series?
Wolzien captures the social dynamics clearly. For instance, the parents and teachers aren’t friends, which Susan questions, “…in this very affluent community the people entrusted with the education of the children were simply not of the same social class as the parents?” You cannot tell who is a good person based on what they seem like, though. One mother told Susan she had a goal to get a mink coat before her 40th birthday, and another mother said hers was to get her kid to eat vegetables. Without much thought, Susan claims the mink fur lady was materialistic, but would do anything for another person, but the vegetable lady? “Oh, her. She’s an asshole.”
Because the community is wealthy, and the novel was published in 1988, the mothers are homemakers and the fathers are income earners. Officer Kathleen Somerville looks down on the community for that reason. She explains her disgust to Detective Fortesque:
These women don’t work for what they have. Their husbands buy it for them. They don’t have anything real to do. It’s like the women’s movement passed them by. Look at where the murders took place: a ladies’ lunch and a discriminatory country club. How nineteen-fifties can you get? These women are thirty years behind the times. It’s not that I don’t like them. I just can’t take them seriously.
Women who are homemakers because they can afford to be, and many with nannies and other hired help, are in direct contrast to a woman like Officer Somerville. The rub is everywhere, though; her superior officer, Detective Fortesque, often sends her on “womanly” tasks, like comforting victims and getting coffee. He also can’t keep his eyes off her stockings, garters, and skirt.
The social dynamics aren’t limited to gender, though. We’re assuming these wealthy characters are white given how books published in the 1980s only tend to describe the race or nationality of non-white characters. When the suggestion that the wealthy white folks and (gasp!) their kids are using drugs, Officer Somerville can’t believe it despite having worked on a narcotics squad. Not only is New York City a half-an-hour drive, but wealth means the money to buy drugs. Officer Somerville argues it’s the “poverty-plagued urban area that breeds dependence on drugs.” Shows what she knows.
Although readers don’t spend nearly as much time in Susan’s head, it’s her honest thoughts about being a wife and mother expected to volunteer that still does me in. Although it’s crass, I understood what Susan meant when she thought she would kill herself than get pregnant again, given that her children are tweens. A fellow mother who is pregnant (again) believes “every baby a blessing,” something Susan disagrees with. The cracks aren’t unique to Susan. After a fellow PTA member calls, this time to cajole Susan into volunteering for the fund-raising committee, both women wonder why both of the deceased were on a committee no one wants to run. Susan is told, “Do you know how hard it is to find someone willing to do that shit?”
Wolzien captures the dynamics among women who are expected to volunteer — something that happens in communities that aren’t wealthy, too, which is why I am familiar with it. After the success of some tiny, fancy sandwiches Susan made for last year’s PTA luncheon, she’s cornered into making them again. What’s so hard about bringing sandwiches people like?
I mean, when someone says, “Oh, will you make those wonderful little sandwiches you bought last year? We all loved them soooooo much,” you can’t refuse, can you? …if she had any spine at all, [Susan] would have told Martha Hallard that she didn’t have the time, the energy, or the desire to repeat that particular performance, and that, if she had known how much work they were going to be, she wouldn’t have made them the first time either.
Wolzien must have realized people liked Susan the best for being a real personality compared to the detective and officer, so I’m curious when she started writing from almost exclusively Susan’s perspective. Perhaps in The Fortieth Birthday Body (#2)?

