It’s that time of year again: looking back and what the heck happened at Grab the Lapels. Frequently, I have people tell me that they didn’t realize I don’t review books written by authors who identify as men at GTL. Perhaps because I still read books by male authors, and add their covers to my TBR on the Sunday Lowdown? Let’s first compare how many books I read by people who identify as men vs. women/non-binary:
While women and non-binary authors dominate, I was surprised that almost 20% of my reading included books by men. However, this figure includes all books that I read or attempted to read. That does not mean 20% of the books I completed were by men. Let’s look closer:
I love that this chart is like a speed gauge. As you can see, I picked up and did not finish 31 books this year — almost 20%. Now, you may be eyeballing that 20% suspiciously and thinking, “Did Melanie not finish any book by a man?” No, these numbers do nor correlate. I DNF’d plenty of books by women, too. The main reason? Largely, I did not finish audiobooks that had narrators I had a hard time understanding, or books that were ignorant (racist, fatphobic, ableist) right away. Sometimes, offensive books are a product of their time, so let’s look at that:
Post-2009 dominates the chart above, but I still encountered some books that included unnecessary bigoted language and dumped them. And then I read novels from the 1910s that were more forward-thinking. Surprises here? Yes! I can’t believe I read so many new books. The 2020s bar includes any book published in 2020 or 2021, so that was a lot of new material for me. But why so many new books? Part of my big goal this year was to get through books I own. It doesn’t help when I see a new book and pre-order it (woops), but I did make great headway on what I read:
More than any other chart, this one makes me happy. Look at all the books I read (or DNF’d) from my own collection. Any book that I did not massively love and foresee me reading again in the future went into the Little Free Library box near my home. It felt great to be unburdened by a large collection of unread books that can now be loved in someone else’s hands. Some books I didn’t get rid of, though, because they are digital. In fact, digital was the way to go in 2021:
Because we did not have access to vaccines until April, much of the early days I wasn’t going to my library, I was checking out library e-books from home. Also, because I want to reduce my physical book collection to save space and reduce allergens, any book I purchase is likely a digital copy. Audiobooks are a close second because all my commute time to and from school (50 minutes one way) meant going through audiobooks pretty quickly in 2021.
And lastly, which kinds of books did I spend all my time on?
Because Jackie @ Death by Tsundoku and I were finishing our #ReadingValdemar challenge, I’m not surprised there are so many fantasy/paranormal books listed. I also read a series of novellas about a paranormal investigator cat and another about werewolves, both by S.M. Reine. I was perplexed by the number of multi-genre novels I read, ones that were both science fiction and post-apocalypse, or journalism and bildungsroman and thriller, or philosophy and a quest, etc. While they are the hardest to “sell” to another reader when I write my reviews, multi-genre novels are my favorite for how they make the most of the best of different genres.
Which books left a lasting impression? 2021 had a few books that lived in my brain rent free, ones I kept returning to while I worked and studied, read new novels and drove around, cooked and showered. Here are the ten that stuck with me the most:
- The Street by Ann Petry
- A Loss for Words by Lou Ann Walker
- The Albino Album by Chavisa Woods
- The Bonfire of the Vanities by Tom Wolfe
- Laura Rider’s Masterpiece by Jane Hamilton
- Woman on the Edge of Time by Marge Piercy
- The Country of Ice Cream Star by Sandra Newman
- When Darkness Loves Us by Elizabeth Engstrom
- Herland by Charlotte Perkins Gilman
- Immobility by Brian Evenson
Is it a coincidence that 8/10 of these books I read with another person? No. I’m learning that the best reading experiences are not done alone, that the best of reading is loving the experience with someone else, whether it’s your mom or spouse, or your friend on a Hawaiian vacation or darling chum in England. Interested in reading a book with me? Add some titles and time periods in the comments so we can work something out.
What will happen at Grab the Lapels in 2022? I’m leaning toward:
- My old system of reading the oldest and newest book I own each month
- A book with a fat female protagonist
- More books by and about D/deaf people
- A category for either a library book or re-reading a book I own so I can review and then decide if I should keep it
- Really getting into the S.M. Reine Descentverse series. I’m still trying to decide if I should review one book at a time or a whole sub-series like I did in the past.
- Biscuit Book Club will continue, and I look forward to doing some buddy reads as well.
I agree, the best reading experiences are often those we share with other people! Happy new year – looking forward to reading with you some more this year!
LikeLike
Thanks, Lou! I’ll email you soon about reading The Left Hand of Darkness. I’m thinking maybe near the end of January?
LikeLike
I love LHoD. I’m really busy book-wise at the end of January but let us know when you start and I’ll try and have it read too, just so I can comment properly.
LikeLike
Will do!
LikeLike
Sounds great!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Your graphics always win! Curious about the genres – some are obvious if you were sorting them yourself, but others I never really understand eg. ‘women’s’ and ‘men’s’ fiction.
LikeLike
I chose “women’s” and “men’s” fiction as categories because I realized that it’s easy to think of books about women as romance or domestic life, something like that, but what I really mean is a book about women or a woman that largely concerns issues that face women. For example, that may be a woman trying to get a job in a male-dominated field or a woman working as a hair stylist, or a woman caring for grandchildren because her own adult child died. Whereas men’s fiction might be more geared toward a bunch of men who teach at a community college together, or single men raising children, or men taking a road trip. I don’t want people to think all men’s fiction is military and hunting and sea captains, or some such. It’s not a perfect categorization, but when I finished each book, I thought, “This work was about men/women doing things men/women cared about” rather than a more obvious genre.
LikeLike
I would love to do a buddy read with you! I don’t know what or when though lol.
I really need to try to focus on reading books I own but also, this next year’s goal is going to force me to buy more books so that collection is going to keep growing. :3
LikeLike
If Dani wants to do something spooky with us, we could aim for Halloween. I’m not sure I’m up for a 1,400 page King novel, but there are some cool horror novels out there. I bought two in October that I heard about in Paperbacks from Hell that I’m saving for the 2022 spooky season.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I’m sure she would probably be down for that. You’re going to have to remind me though because there is no way I will remember this plan by then lol.
LikeLike
As long as Sugar and Scream are going strong, I’ll remmeber.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Oooh, I’d love to read something spooky with the two of you for Halloween. Count me in! 😀
LikeLike
Huzzah!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Great analysis. I think cross-genre books are the best. An ‘ideal’ book for me would be Female/literary/SF/Coming of Age and young women seem to be writing those kinds of books now.
I have two of your top 10 in my TBR – Woman on the Edge of Time (Audible) and Herland (eReader).
And Hi to Biscuit. Keep commenting!
LikeLike
I love dystopian/made-up language/raggedy girls and women characters/road trips.
I found Woman on the Edge of Time hard to listen to, so I abandoned the audibook and got the ebook.
I told Biscuit you left her a comment 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Fun stats! I don’t track my DNF’s beyond a special dedicated shelf on Goodreads. Congrats on reading so many of your own books. That’s something I think many book bloggers struggle with. Happy New Year, Melanie!
LikeLike
I think a lot of readers feel conflicted about whether to DNF a book, so I figure if I show them “Look! I have so many!” maybe they will feel more confident about not reading something that is making them miserable.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I applaud anyone normalizing DNF-ing. 👍
LikeLiked by 1 person
Love your stats and graphics! You had a great reading year. I love Marge Piercy’s Woman on the Edge of Time. I first read it in a women’s lit course in college and it turned me on to other Piercy books including her awesome poetry. Happy New Year!
LikeLike
I didn’t realize Piercy wrote poetry, and I haven’t read her other works. Perhaps I should a “yet”? Happy New Year, Stefanie!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am actually surprised that you read so many books by men. And well done on reading so many books you own!
LikeLike
Thank you! I believe a lot of the books by guys are audiobooks, or something I read to Nick.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Melanie! I wanted to stop by and wish you a happy new year (looks like 2021 was a good one in terms of reading anyway!) and say that I’m sorry I haven’t stopped by to say hi recently. I’ve been thinking of you and miss our chats! I hope you are well.
LikeLike
I’ve been thinking about you too! Every once in a while I pop onto Goodreads to see if anyone has messaged me, and I see you’re quite active on there. The Cromwell book sounds like a slog. Girl, let it go. I hope you and your daughter had a great New Year’s Eve together!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ha! I’m at a point now where Cromwell has grown on me and it makes more sense, but it took me 200+ pages 😂.
Send me an email anytime- or GR message (I do check GR quite a bit during the day). My email has changed- gmail has shut down my old account (long story) but you can get me at the same one with @hotmail.com instead (it’s an oldie).
LikeLike
Melanie- I’m pleased to hear it our little book club will continue. I had assumed it was on auto renew! Happy New Year! 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
LikeLike
Biscuit Book Club is ready for 2022! But is 2022 ready for us??
LikeLiked by 1 person
Congratulations on your reading accomplishments in the past year!
LikeLike
Thanks 🙂
LikeLike
A great round-up! I like doing read-alongs, I’m not sure I’d have got through Roots without Bill and Buried in Print, or not so quickly. I am always up for them, not sure if we overlap enough, though. Fancy reading a Larry McMurtry for my reading project this year? Happy reading for 2022 and I will look forward to your posts.
LikeLike
I also read Roots with a buddy — Books by the Cup, whom I don’t see blogging very often but I know still reads and shares on Goodreads. We had a great time breaking the book up and talking about it bit by bit. Happy 2022!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Your first book/last book is an interesting way to balance out the shiny new and the older purchases.
LikeLike
I’d done this in past years and then didn’t in 2020 for reasons I cannot remember. I need to clean up some of these books that I’ve owned for waaaay too long. At the very least, I need to start the book and decide if I’m even still interested, and if not, off to the Free Little Library it goes.
LikeLike
I’m so impressed by your pie charts – your academic roots are showing 🙂
Ok question about reducing the amount of books you own. I’m totally down with this, you know I give away books as soon as I finish reading them, but what do you mean by reducing allergens – are books an allergen? Or just like, a dust collector? I’m so curious now!
LikeLike
Oh yeah, books are actually really dirty. I wrote a post about it, and here’s the section about why books are dirty:
According to a chemical engineer, there are several reasons the paper in your physical books breaks down. Some are pretty basic: if you aren’t dusting incessantly, your books are breaking down. If you keep food near your bookshelves, the paper can break down. Open windows, poor ventilation, and obvious problems like a leaky roof all affect your books. Now, if you’re like me and suffering from ridiculous allergies right now because the trees are trying to get it on, then you know that having items in your house that collect dust and even mold spores is bad for your health.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh no….I do have seasonal allergies which seem to get worse as I age, although its also VERY dry here in Calgary so not sure if that helps or makes things worse.
LikeLike
Okay, I’m pretty sure I’m allergic to my cat, a cat I’ve had for 12 years. This is a recent discover, and now part of me is like, “Kitty, you old yet? I’d like to breathe and smell at some point again…” and then I feel like a jerk.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I actually suspect I’m a bit allergic to our cat too but…it’s not bad enough to really matter. What if someone babysat her for a few weeks and you could see if that helps? Mind you, cats aren’t huge fans of sleepvers haha
LikeLike
Well, I’m less stuffy at school, so … 😬😬😬
LikeLiked by 1 person